Julien Duvivier最好的作品之一也是他认为自己所有默片中最喜欢的一部。
Summary
Bullied by his matriarchal mother, abused by his siblings, ignored by his father, Poil de Carotte's childhood is as miserable as it could be. An illegitimate child, he is the main reason for the enmity which exists between his parents, who continue to live together just to keep up appearances. In the end, Poil de Carotte's suffering becomes more than he can bear...
Review
Drawing heavily on the poignant novel by Jules Renard on which it is based, Poil de carotte is a modest yet appealing film which has stood the test of time mainly because of the quality of its acting performances and its inherent humanity. It is more memorable than Julien Duvivier's earlier silent version of 1925, also named Poil de Carotte.
The part of Poil de Carotte was played by 11 year old Robert Lynen, who was alleged to have been discovered whilst walking down the Champs-Elysées in Paris. Lynen is totally captivating and the film made him an instant star, launching what looked like becoming a very promising film career – until he was shot dead whilst fighting against the Germans in 1944. Harry Baur, a legendary stage and film actor (who also died during World War II, allegedly at the hands of the Gestapo), also turns in a typically fine performance. The reconciliation between father and son at the end of the film provides its most enduring image, enough to melt the heart of all but the most stoical of spectators.
6分真的不能再高了…剧本有问题,导演的“碗”其实就没有扣住主题,人物刻画上很法国,身份上的落差并没有表现的很突出,两人的爱情很炙热,但是艺术上没啥升华…就是一部很过时的影片。
开头有点无聊,中间开始有点意思了,但总体还是属于拼接体,没什么惊喜,结尾还可以
最顶尖的艺术家和艺术品往往都是超前的。无论创意,还是审美,都超越他们所处的时代。这是艺术家们的苦恼,因为明明都是无价作品,却不能即时变现,甚至导致一生穷困潦倒。艾菲尔已经算幸运儿了。他的自由女神像比较接地气,给他积累了一定的名望和财富。而埃菲尔铁塔的设计和建造过程就没那么顺利了。
节奏为什么这么差,剪辑为什么这么差!完全没有体现出一点现实与小说之间的“交织”与“层次感”,以“三张假币”为线索串起来的故事算是精巧有趣,但显然撑不起快两个小时的体量,甚至没有豆瓣上的剧情简介有趣。电影也许想体现出一点“黑色电影”的气质,表达一些对“作者权利”,“文学与现实”的思考,但结果显得不伦不类。PS:KIRINJI的配乐出现的次数不多,但每次出现都是亮点
就希望龙也老师继续贡献"殉情卖书"这样的扎心金句。
故事是蛮有创意的,但没头没尾,故弄玄虚,如能用点心多好
有点类似于《墓地邂逅》。叙事拉跨逻辑不清,但比《昆池岩》强得多。
说好的造塔呢?故事觉得差一口气啊。。。
以及女鬼永远摆脱不了贞子造型!
一座地标拔地而起,一场赌博贯穿几十年最终去完成;能感受到高成本投入之下,所创造的不可名状之美以及对所有将要克服的难题与障碍的生动表现。只可惜立项之时就明确要把更多的篇幅分给情感生活的纠缠,也很随意地插入按照年份推进的建筑故事之中,或许抵消了成为更出色与共通的传记片可能。算上《尼罗河上的惨案》,Emma Mackey在大银幕给人的感觉是糟糕的,整个就担心Frances O'Connor的那部《艾米莉》了。
确实符合商业片的感觉,算挺好看。尤其是最后建塔攻关阶段拍得真不错
男主书店和人妻不伦相当有实感。3000万真假钞的谜团,3张钞票引发的蝴蝶风暴,一家三口的失踪,绿帽和黑帮。开篇元叙事吉光片羽的玩的挺高级。非常遗憾剧本张力和悬念没能成功搭建起来,越到后面越莫名其妙。垮掉与寡淡感让人略感不满。
以为是纪录片,来看塔怎么建成的,谁知道看了个埃菲尔的浪漫野史……爱情故事有些老套,可是男女主的眼睛真的太很会说话,公开场合没有台词,却依然勾魂摄魄,那场舞会跳得简直比滚床单还要性感,而且青年和中年的处理和把握都非常好,男主在马车上抬头就泪目的镜头真是难受了。
剧情比较含糊,感觉是男主最后是回到02年,所以听到两人说96年时明白他们已经死了。
作为一部传记片来说有些太简单了,不过罗曼好帅哦
没啥意思,但是和我妈打赌结局,赢了一百块钱💰
太闷了,看不下去。。但是得到个知识点,设计埃菲尔铁塔这人也是建造自由女神像那人。。
拿个降魔杵就敢闯死了几十人的凶宅公寓作实也是牛批!血月之日地缚灵居然还能折叠时空也是扯!创意不错,就是画面太黑了,看起很费力,一惊一乍的!地缚灵这种题材应该属于是我大国内的才是!#电影 #鬼门2021
建塔很有趣,但我看和艾玛谈恋爱更有趣,完全没空关注建塔啊哈哈。导演是认认真真当一个传记片在拍,太正经了也。
4.5 故事很有趣哎,就是前半部分节奏比较慢。看完很想买原著看一下
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved