Haunted by the memory of Walter Holderlin, a soldier he killed during World War I, French musician Paul Renard (Phillips Holmes) confesses to a priest (Frank Sheridan), who grants him absolution. Using the address on a letter he found on the dead man's body, Paul then travels to Germany to find his family.
As anti-French sentiment continues to permeate Germany, Dr. Holderlin (Lionel Barrymore) initially refuses to welcome Paul into his home, but changes his mind when his son's fiancée Elsa identifies him as the man who has been leaving flowers on Walter's grave. Rather than reveal the real connection between them, Paul tells the Holderlin family he was a friend of their son, who attended the same musical conservatory he did.
Although the hostile townspeople and local gossips disapprove, the Holderlins befriend Paul, who finds himself falling in love with Elsa (Nancy Carroll). When she shows Paul her former fiancé's bedroom, he becomes distraught and tells her the truth. She convinces him not to confess to Walter's parents, who have embraced him as their second son, and Paul agrees to forego easing his conscience and stays with his adopted family. Dr. Holderlin presents Walter's violin to Paul, who plays it while Elsa accompanies him on the piano.
The film's original title, The Man I Killed, was changed to The Fifth Commandment to avoid giving "wrong impressions in the minds of the public about the character of the story." It ultimately was released as Broken Lullaby.
和蜘蛛侠3不相上下，甚至更劣一筹
"I love you in every universe"
个人感觉比招魂系列更好！虽然本胆小鬼只敢快进着很小声的看，但还是被吓得吱哇乱叫。温子仁搞气氛已经是基本操作。这部电影其实更体现了电影体裁的特殊性，故事并不新鲜，说白了就是人格分裂，隐藏人格干坏事主人格不知道，两个人格争夺身体控制权。但如何进行视觉展现是进行了创新的，比如加百列从后脑长出来，把人的背面当成正面，折胳膊折腿，进行一系列的打斗…这才是这部电影独有的精彩，虽然可能引进版删了一些镜头。从写毕业作品以来我也一直在反思，关注文本是好的，但影像亦是电影本体的重要部分。如果有充分的视觉创新，旧瓶装新酒其实也未尝不可。
显得非常违和不自洽
迷幻的乐风以及雷同斯嘉丽和嘎嘎的混合容颜，关键是唱功也在线，不错风格的演唱会纪录片…
所以现在所有好莱坞演员都是漫威打工人了……
6.8分。所以，打开多元宇宙就是为了这么草率地杀掉我们喜欢的角色？《天启星战争2.0》？
西景镇明明是给旺达上了一堂课，而不是让她变得更疯狂😭👊👊你让她在西景镇收获的成长、人们的牺牲都变得全无意义😭👊👊
五彩斑斓的高清光影舞台
只要温子仁不再拍什么驱魔电影，那它就是一部好片子。
用主流商业片的思路来拍铅黄B级片的下场就是现代技术的过度入侵，空间感一流的调度成功地被人造感十足的布景和CG拉掉价，尽管其间各种无差别杀戮依然能看到温子仁早期的各类邪典恶趣味，可最后拥抱真善美直接泄气—-和soho街一个调性，各种没劲。
穿越那段特效好棒，瑞秋又穿婚纱了。大体上比第四阶段前几部好多了
感觉这部电影有点莫名其妙，旺达莫名其妙就发疯各种找孩子。结尾奇异博士变三只眼了，又是下一部预告。
新作至少比之前的同类作品略好。拍摄技术毋庸置疑地好，但故事原创元素太弱，就是个迷影大融合，顺便还给漫威宇宙创造个新成员。另外，温子仁拍的动作片真比恐怖片好太多。（对温子仁的恐怖片彻底放弃）
总觉得《分裂》也好，《24个比利》的多重人格也好，《惊魂记》的双重人格也好，这种被触发的人格分裂是被迷乱了的腐朽意志，既然道不明这种虚假空壳，恶性肿瘤就是搭载邪恶意志的最佳存在方式。所以这一次，用生物本体与生物异质去践行还原主义，所以这一次大道至简，没有迂回曲折的蒙太奇和结构复杂的架空观，纯真回溯到铅黄时代，还杂糅了科幻的前奏与悬疑的节奏。如果说之前看温导是想求得精神的折磨和智性的折磨，那这次单刀直入式铺陈开来，这是导演控场功力的完胜绝杀，并且切切实实被卷进最后30分钟极其逻辑自洽的一反转再反转，脑洞合理到大呼过瘾！！！温子仁是个神人！！！
故事开始的其实挺恶俗的 一步步揭露出邪恶的本质。后半段特效看的真过瘾和有趣。如果结局加百利杀人后越窗逃跑 消失在城市的夜色中 岂不更加不寒而栗！
电影公映前造势太猛，猜想太多，导致电影在预期内，没有太大惊喜。
恐怖爽片？温子仁导演在题材创新上的魄力真是让人大开眼界！
录像＋通灵，还是有招魂系列的影子，刚开始以为是通灵，结果是通脑，悬疑揭开后，灵异的气氛没了，就成了有点B级片血腥暴力，结局的意思还有第二部？感觉不太可。
粉丝向/ 开着吃午饭/ 事实证明除了bad guy 很难喜欢Billie其他歌
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
